Ongoing tracking of the real time web …

The last post that I did about real time web data mixed data with a commentary and a fake headline about how data is sometimes misunderstood in regards to the real time web.    This post repeats some of that data but the focus of the post is the data.   I will update the post periodically with relevant data that we see at betaworks or that others share with us.   To that end this post is done in reverse order with the newest data on top.

Tracking the real time web data

The measurement tools we have still only sometimes work for counting traffic to web pages and they certainly dont track or measure traffic in streams let alone aggregate up the underlying ecosystems that are emerging around these new markets.  At betaworks we spend a lot of time looking at and tracking this underlying data set.   It’s our business and its fascinating.   Like many companies each of the individual businesses at betaworks have fragments of data sets but because betaworks acts as ecosystem of companies we can mix and match the data to get results that are more interesting and hopefully offer greater insight

——————————-

(i) tumblr growth for the last half of 2009

Another data point re: growth of the real time web through the second half of last year through to Jan 18th of this year.  tumblr continues to kill it.     I read this interesting post yesterday about how tumblr is leading in its  category through innovation and simple, effective, product design.   The compete numbers quoted in that post are less impressive than these directly measured quantcast numbers.


(h) Twitter vs. the Twitter Ecosystem

Fred Wilson’s post adds some solid directional data on the question of the size of the ecosystem.   “You can talk about Twitter.com and then you can talk about the Twitter ecosystem. One is a web site. The other is a fundamental part of the Internet infrastructure. And the latter is 3-5x bigger than the former and that delta is likely to grow even larger.”

(g) Some early 2010 data points re: the Real Time Web

  • Twitter: Jan 11th was the highest usage day ever (source: @ev via techcrunch)
  • Tweetdeck: did 4,143,687 updates on Jan 8, yep 4m. Or, 48 per second (source: Iain Dodsworth / tweetdeck internal data)
  • Foursquare: Jan 9th biggest day ever.    1 update or check-in per second (source: twitter and techcrunch)
  • Daily Booth: in past 30 days more than 10mm uniques (source: dailybooth internal data)
  • bit.ly: last week was the largest week ever for clicks on bit.ly links. 564m were clicked on in total. On the Jan 6th there were a record of 98m decodes.    1100 clicks every second.

(f) Comparing the real time web vs. Google for the second half of 2009

Andrew Parker commented on the last post that the chart displaying the growth trends was hard to decipher and that it maybe simpler to show month over month trending.  It turns out the that month over month is also hard to decipher.   What is easier to read is this summary chart.    It shows the average month over month growth rates for the RT web sites (the average from Chart A).   Note 27.33% is the average growth rate for the real time web companies in 2009 — that’s astounding.    The comparable number for the second half of 2009 was 10.5% a month — significantly lower but still a very big number for m/m growth.

(e) Ongoing growth of the real time stream in the second half of 2009

This is a question people have asked me repeatedly in the past few weeks.  Did the real time stream grow in Q4 2009?    It did.    Not at the pace that it grew during q1-q3, but our data at betaworks confirms continued growth.   One of the best proxies we use for directional trending in the real time web are the bit.ly decodes.   This is the raw number of bit.ly links that are clicked on across the web.    Many of these clicks occur within the Twitter ecosystem, but a large number are outside of Twitter, by people and by machines — there is a surprising amount of diversity within the real time stream as I posted about a while back.

Two charts are displayed below.    On the bottom are bit.ly decodes (blue) and encodes (red)  running through the second half of last year.    On the top is a different but related metric.   Another betaworks company is Twitterfeed.    Twitterfeed is the leading platform enabling publishers to post from their sites into Twitter and Facebook.    This chart graphs the total number of feeds processed (blue) and the total number of publishers using Twitterfeed, again through the second half of the year (note if the charts inline are too small to read you can click though and see full size versions).   As you can see similar the left hand chart — at Twitterfeed the growth was strong for the entire second half of 2009.

Both these charts illustrate the ongoing shift that is taking place in terms of how people use the real time web for navigation, search and discovery.    My preference is to look at real user interactions as strong indicators of user behavior.   For example I actually find Google trends more useful often than comScore, Compete or the other “page” based measurement services.   As interactions online shift to streams we are going to have to figure out how measurement works. I feel like today we are back to the early days of the web when people talked about “hits” — it’s hard to parse the relevant data from the noise.  The indicators we see suggest that the speed at which this shift to the real time web is taking place is astounding.   Yet it is happening in a fashion that I have seen a couple of times before.

(d) An illustration of the step nature of social growth. bit.ly weekly decodes for the second half of 2009.

Most social networks I have worked with have grown in a step function manner.  You see this clearly when you zoom into the bit.ly data set and look at weekly decodes, illustrated above.   You often have to zoom in and out of the data set to see and find the steps but they are usually there.     Sometimes they run for months — either up or sideways.    You can see the steps in Facebook growth in 2009.    I saw effect up close with ICQ, AIM, Fotolog, Summize and now with bit.ly.   Someone smarter than me has surely figured out why these steps occur.    My hypothesis is that as social networks grow they jump in a sporadic fashion from one dense cluster of relationships to a new one.   The upward trajectory is the adoption cycle of that new, dense cluster and the flat part of the step is the period between the step to next cluster.     Blended in here there are clearly issues of engagement vs. trial.   But it’s hard to weed those out from this data set.   As someone mentioned to me in regards to the last post this is a property of scale-free networks.

(c) Google and Amazon in 2009

Google and Amazon — this is what it looked like in 2009:

It’s basically flat.     Pretty much every user in the domestic US is on Google for search and navigation and on Amazon for commerce — impressive baseline numbers but flat for the year (source: Quantcast).  So then lets turn to Twitter.

(b) Twitter – an estimate of Twitter.com and the Twitter ecosystem

Much ink has been spilt over Twitter.com’s growth in the second half of the year.   During the first half of the year Twitter’s experience hyper growth — and unprecedented media attention.    In the second half of the year the media waned, the service went through what I suspect was a digestion phase — that step again?     Steps aside — because I dont in anyway seek to represent Twitter Inc. — there are two questions that in my mind haven’t been answered fully:

(i) what international growth in the second half of 2009?, that was clearly a driver for Facebook in ’09.  Recent data suggests growth continued to be strong.

(ii) what about the ecosystem.

Unsurprisingly its the second question that interests me the most.    So what about that ecosystem?    We know that approx 50% of the interactions with the Twitter API occur outside of Twitter.com but many of those aren’t end user interactions.     We also know that as people adopt and build a following on Twitter they often move up to use one of the client or vertical specifics applications to suit their “power” needs.   At TweetDeck we did a survey of our users this past summer.     The data we got suggested 92% of them then use Tweetdeck everyday — 51% use Twitter more frequently since they started using TweetDeck.  So we know there is a very engaged audience on the clients.     We also know that most of the clients arent web pages — they are flash, AIR, coco, iPhone app’s etc. all things that the traditional measurement companies dont track.

What I did to estimate the relative growth of the Twitter ecosystem is the following.   I used Google Trends and compiled data for Twitter and the key clients.    I then scaled that chart over the Twitter.com traffic.   Is it correct? — no.   Is it made up? — no.   It’s a proxy and this is what it looks like (again, you can click the chart to see a larger version).

Similar to the Twitter.com traffic you see the flattening out of the ecosystem in the summer.    But you see growth in the forth quarter that returns to the summer time levels.     I suspect if you could zoom in and out of this the way I did above you would see those steps again.

(a) The Real Time Web in 2009

Add in Facebook (blue) and Meebo (green) both steaming ahead — Meebo had a very strong end of year.    And then tile on top the bit.ly data and the Twitterfeed numbers (bit.ly on the right hand scale) and you have an overall picture of growth of the real time web vs. Google and Amazon.   As t

Trackbacks

  1. [...] John Borthwick, co-founder of Betaworks, parent company to bit.ly, twitterfeed, tweetdeck, chartbeat, and many other interesting web services, posted yesterday on “Ongoing tracking of the real time web …” [...]

  2. [...] Jump to Comments Betaworks’ John Borthwick recently posted the informative Ongoing tracking of the real time web…  Combined with Fred Wilson’s AVC post Twitter v. the Twitter Ecosystem, these two [...]

  3. [...] John Borthwick, CEO Betaworks among many of his pursuits, discusses real-time data on his “THINK Musings” blog. In his post, he notes recent all-time usage highs for real-time data sources such as Twitter, Foursquare and even URL shortener, bit.ly. He adds that real-time “stream” growth may have slowed in Q4 2009 in comparison to previous quarters. Read more data about the data. [...]

  4. [...] John Borthwick, co-founder of Betaworks, parent company to bit.ly, twitterfeed, tweetdeck, chartbeat, and many other interesting web services, posted yesterday on “Ongoing tracking of the real time web …” [...]

  5. [...] recent post byJohn Borthwick on his blog “Think Musings” may provide some encouraging [...]

  6. [...] the U.S., at least, the greater Twitter ecosystem is estimated to have twice as much traffic as Twitter.com [...]

  7. [...] the U.S., at least, the greater Twitter ecosystem is estimated to have twice as much traffic as Twitter.com [...]

  8. [...] The ComScore numbers only look at the site twitter.com, many twitter users (like me) almost never access twitter.com, and use a “client” instead. The client is a stand-alone piece of software on your computer, or a site that somehow improves Twitter for the user. This non-Twitter.com usage of Twitter is becoming known as the “Twitter eco-system”. [...]